There is perhaps no decision harder than choosing an engagement ring. As you know, diamonds – or coloured gemstones – are forever. So whether you’re just dreaming for the future (we know about that hidden Pinterest board!), are looking to lock in an appointment with a jeweller like yesterday, or want to pop the question with a unique engagement ring they can’t not say yes to, we’ve rounded up 10 of the best engagement ring stores in Sydney in 2025.
While the One Fine Day Directory can really kick off your wedding planning, this list will get you on the right track when looking for that ‘dream’ ring. We’ve packed all the info, Instagram accounts and photos of their most beautiful engagement rings in the one list. Looking for an oval engagement ring? No stress. Hoping for a coloured stone? You betcha. Need to begin the hunt and work out what you like best? We’ve got you! As Beyonce said, ‘If you liked it then you shoulda put a ring on it’ – but only a ring from one of these stores, OK?
1. The Cut Jewellery
The Cut Jewellery is a fresh, new Australian and family-owned jewellery brand that is fast becoming a name to watch. Already worn on the red carpet by the likes of Sylvia Jeffries and Edwina Bartholomew, The Cut offers a taste of ethical luxury with their bespoke range of lab-grown diamonds.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT THE CUT JEWELLERY
What makes The Cut Jewellery different?
Although mined diamonds have long dominated the jewellery industry, lab-grown diamonds are quickly disrupting this ethically questionable practice. This is why the work of The Cut Jewellery is so important. While naturally mined diamonds can often be extracted in unregulated and dangerous conditions, lab-grown diamonds are made safely within a laboratory. Chemically, optically and physically, lab-grown diamonds are identical to mined diamonds, offering the exact same sparkle and brilliance – without the ethical concerns.
Why try The Cut Jewellery?
The Cut Jewellery was founded by TV Journalist Talitha Cummins, who started in the diamond industry over 20 years ago before moving into TV journalism. She joins forces with her uncle’s decades of diamond and jewellery experience, and her cousin’s masterful eye for design.
With the launch of The Cut Jewellery, Cummins is determined to offer Australians a more ethical and sustainable alternative to mined diamonds. The range, which specialises in bespoke engagement rings and fine jewellery, is of exceptional quality and provides a fresh perspective on traditional luxury, free from unethical conditions.
All pieces are crafted in Sydney, Australia, with buyers able to experience a face-to-face consultation in Paddington or collaborate and purchase online. As part of every consult, Kara, Head Designer, will use the latest software to design each piece and offer clients a detailed sneak peek before it is made. If you’re looking for a personalised and bespoke experience from top jewellery stores in Sydney, you can’t go past The Cut Jewellery.
Real customer reviews:
“I really wanted an ethical diamond choice and I was thrilled to be able to tick that box without having to compromise on the quality of the product.” – Brittany Bennett
“Talitha and The Cut Jewellery made my engagement experience out of this world. My partner AJ had such a special time in the months leading up to the day creating my forever ring! The design and diamonds used are just exceptional & I feel like the luckiest girl in the world to wear it every day. Talitha & the team have exceeded my expectations.” – Eloise Soiher
2. Ernesto Buono
What makes Ernesto Buono Fine Jewellery different?
Discover the epitome of fine jewellery craftsmanship at Ernesto Buono Fine Jewellery. When entering this store, you’ll enjoy meticulously crafted diamond pieces and lab diamond jewellery that stand the test of time.
Ernesto Buono offers personalised consultations to ensure you find the perfect piece for any occasion and their team of experts will ensure you choose the right piece for you.
Experience the magic of jewellery that tells a story of love, family, and enduring beauty, with Ernesto Buono.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT ERNESTO BUONO FINE JEWELLERY
Why try Ernesto Buono Fine Jewellery?
Ernesto Buono Jewellery carries both natural diamonds and lab grown diamonds, so there are options to suit all needs. But no matter which type of diamond you choose, you can be guaranteed that it will be of the highest quality and sparkle beautifully.
Real customer reviews:
‘I could not recommend a place more! Ernesto, Steff and all the other lovely staff are incredible. My partner bought my engagement ring which we designed together here and also my wedding band recently and not only is the craftsmanship amazing but the detail and quality is unmatched. I will not go anywhere else again for all my jewellery needs.’ – Malcolm Wood
‘I picked up some custom jewellery including an engagement ring, wedding ring and a few other bespoke pieces from Ernesto Buono Fine Jewellery today. Ernesto’s attention to detail, advice, communication and quality of workmanship is second to none and comparable to large jewellery houses. I have absolutely no hesitation in recommending Ernesto’s services and will personally definitely be returning for more.’ – Ceyda Oz
3. Cushla Whiting
When you begin your hunt for an engagement ring, there’s no doubt you want your jewellery to be akin to you in terms of beliefs. At CUSHLA WHITING, the belief is that fine jewellery should be both extraordinary and approachable. For this reason, they have obtained an extensive archive of ethically sourced diamonds and rare gemstones.
Drawing upon co-founder Cushla Whiting’s background as an architect, the jewellery brand’s ethos is heavily inspired by architectural principles, all while celebrating a bygone era of craftsmanship.
Each piece is handcrafted in the Melbourne workshop, where traditional techniques converge with a modern design ethos. Whether it is a rare Colombian emerald, an antique diamond, or a coloured sapphire, every design is inspired by the unique character of each stone, making it truly unique in look and in essence.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT CUSHLA WHITING
Why try Cushla Whiting?
At CUSHLA WHITING, the bespoke and the specialised is championed, crafting modern heirlooms for generations to come. The team’s GIA-certified gemologist, Hamish, works from the prestigious Antwerp Diamond Bourse, sourcing the exceptional stones from an established network of ethical suppliers. Then, the brand’s master artisans bring these designs to life through time-honored craftsmanship, resulting in creations that are both striking and wearable.
If the goal is to don a best engagement ring that you’d be hard pressed ever to find on another finger, than an in-person or virtual visit to the team at CUSHLA WHITING is an absolute must.
Real customer reviews:
“We knew after our first meeting with Gen in the Sydney showroom that we wanted Cushla Whiting to make our ring. She was professional, creative and generous with advice and ideas. Communication was also important to us as our diamonds were sourced by Hamish Whiting in Antwerp, our ring was manufactured in Melbourne and we live in Sydney and Canberra. The whole process was professional and seamless and our ring is absolutely stunning. We will definitely get our wedding bands from CW next year.” – Phoebe
4. Natalie Marie Jewellery
Natalie Marie Jewellery is a local designer with big international appeal – Megan Markle even called the brand her ‘very favourite’! Natalie Marie specialise in bespoke engagement rings, with everything handcrafted in their light-filled Avalon studio.
They aim to offer a unique jewellery design experience, cultivating a relaxed and comfortable environment for crafting that one-of-a-kind engagement ring you’re dreaming about. Their Signature Solitaire with either an oval, round or emerald cut diamond is to die for. And if you’re looking to ditch the diamonds, they excel in working with unique semi-precious stones that’ll give your engagement ring the X-factor.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT NATALIE MARIE JEWELLERY
5. Sarah & Sebastian
SARAH & SEBASTIAN are often credited with starting the fine jewellery trend in Australia, so if you’re after a delicate engagement ring, look no further. Designers, Sarah Gittoes and Robert Sebastian Grynkofki, have built the brand that now boasts cult status, championing local manufacturing and designs made to wear every day.
You can meet with their team to design a unique engagement ring using ethically sourced diamonds or choose from a bevy of beautiful designs they feature on their website. All designs are handcrafted in their Sydney workshop for you.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT SARAH & SEBASTIAN
6. Larsen Jewellery
Larsen Jewellery was founded by husband and wife team, Lars and Susie Larsen over a decade ago with one simple premise: Offering high quality and ethically made jewellery directly from the jewellery studio where it is made. Larsen has grown a fair bit since then, but that guiding principle hasn’t changed.
The team at Larsen Jewellery is dedicated to providing outstanding service, exceptional quality jewellery that’s backed by a lifetime guarantee, and a commitment to providing ethically sourced and sustainable products.
LOCATION: LEVEL 5/412-414 GEORGE ST, SYDNEY NSW 2000
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT LARSEN JEWELLERY
Why choose Larsen Jewellery?
Ethically made: 100% carbon neutral, the team offers Fairtrade Gold and donate 10% of profits to charity.
Expert advice from qualified jewellers: Speak directly to the talented craftsmen and learn from their extensive diamond and jewellery knowledge.
Exceptional quality: Larsen Jewellery never compromise on quality. All of their jewellery is Australian made and is backed by a lifetime guarantee.
Quality craftsmanship: The Larsen Jewellery creative team offers the perfect blend of artistry and expertise to bring your jewellery ideas to life. With decades of experience in design and craftsmanship, and incredible attention to detail, you’re guaranteed to fall in love with your piece.
The team also look after our customers long after your jewellery has been collected. As a proud member of the Jewellers Association of Australia and The Gold & Silversmiths Guild of Australia, they abide by their strict code of ethics.s
Real customer reviews:
“The jewellers at Larsen were great to deal with. They were always very friendly, knowledgeable and patient throughout the whole process, from the initial conception of our idea through to its completion. The final pendant was designed beautifully and very well made.” – Scott Stirling
“Absolutely loved my engagement ring from Larsen’s.. amazing quality and craftsmanship and the best customer service! So happy to have had this lovely experience with such a great company ❤️” – Ruby Bourke
7. GREW & CO
If you want an engagement ring that’s truly a showstopper, take a look at Grew & Co. They are renowned for their distinctive asymmetrical designs (think Megan Fox’s engagement ring) that could sit a pretty on your finger alone or be adorned by their exquisite wedding bands too.
Their workshop sits in their flagship Sydney store where a dedicated team produces handcrafted creations through entirely local production. They take pride in ethically sourcing all their stones and if you always thought you were a diamond girl, Grew & Co might just be the ones who sway you with a swoon-worthy coloured stone.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT GREW & CO
8. Baby Anything
Baby Anything, the brainchild of contemporary jewellery designer, Lucie Ferguson, has a unique charm. Yes, she’s Elle Ferguson of Insta-fame’s sister and who designed Elle’s 5-carat engagement ring!
Lucie’s approach to designing engagement rings is all about crafting treasured heirlooms meant to be cherished forever. As well as ethically sourcing materials, Lucy loves to work with existing heirloom jewellery that she can take and re-design into a very special piece. The dedication to sentimental and sustainable design sets Baby Anything apart.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT BABY ANYTHING
9. Mirai Jewellery
Mirai is a Japanese word meaning ‘future’ – and this embodies what they have in their vision when crafting each distinctive engagement ring.
Mathew, the mastermind behind Mirai, specialises in custom jewellery pieces and remodelling, meaning that if you choose Mirai you know you’re getting a one-of-a-kind engagement ring, tailored to your unique preferences an desires. Creating a symbol of your future together that is truly special.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT MIRAI JEWELLERY
10. TOK Jewllers
TOK Jewellers offers a stunning array of engagement rings, both bespoke and ready to wear, making it a challenge to select just one design from their exquisite collection. As a family-owned business since 1974, their experience speaks for itself, assuring you that they truly understand their craft.
All their creations are meticulously made in-house at their Sydney workshop and the designs can be tailored to your preferences, whether it’s the choice of a diamond, coloured gemstone, or precious metal, ensuring your ring is a unique reflection of your love and style.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT TOK JEWELLERS
11. Natasha Schweitzer
The Schweitzer family have been in the jewellery business for a long time. In 1972, then 16-year-old Marion Schweitzer founded the brand and it went on to become one of Australia’s most successful jewellery houses. Today, her daughters Natasha and Alexandra are at the helm, carrying on the family legacy.
The brand is celebrated for its refined beauty and exceptional quality, merging contemporary and minimalist shapes with a touch of nostalgia from bygone eras. Choosing a Natasha Schweitzer engagement ring promises a truly special and timeless experience, infused with the heritage and expertise of the Schweitzer family.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT NATASHA SCHWEITZER
12. Olivia Bond Diamonds
Olivia Bond is a private jeweller, gemmologist, diamond grader and valuer and the person to go to if you’re looking for a really personal engagement ring experience. She specialises in classic engagement rings and works with the brightest stones under the highest quality workmanship.
What makes Olivia’s service a stand out is her dedication to crafting mostly bespoke pieces. This means that she takes the time to truly understand your preferences and desires, working closely with you to design a one-of-a-kind engagement ring. The result is not just a beautiful ring but a family heirloom that will be cherished for generations to come. With Olivia Bond, you can expect a truly personal and unique engagement ring.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT OLIVIA BOND DIAMONDS
13. ENGAGEMENT RING STORES SYDNEY
Nicholas Haywood Jewellery
Nicholas Haywood offers a jewellery concierge that takes you through every step of the engagement ring journey, from choosing the perfect engagement ring, to caring for it in the years to come.
Meet Nicholas and his team at their Sydney design studio to craft a unique engagement ring tailored to your preferences. If you spot something you love in their classic ready-to-wear collection, that’s an option too. They’ll assist you with insurance, ensure safe and personal delivery of your ring once it’s ready and provide regular check-ups and cleaning to keep your precious piece looking its best. It’s a comprehensive package for a truly memorable and worry-free engagement ring experience.
FIND OUT MORE ABOUT NICHOLAS HAYWOOD JEWELLERY
To find even more engagement ring stores, check out the One Fine Day Directory.
Make sure you don’t miss out on the next Sydney One Fine Day Wedding Fair! See all the details and get your tickets right here.
Hero image via @theevokecompany floristry by @ivylanecollective
By Rebecca Bodman
//
One Fine Day contributor
